Two days after the release of the Pennsylvania Grand Jury report on the gut-wrenching abusive incidents by clergy, and subsequent cover-ups by the leadership, the Vatican has released a statement via director of the Holy See Press Office, Greg Burke, that “expresses shame…the pope is on victims’ side”.
Here is the full statement:
I agree with Matthew Schmitz that the sympathetic words are well-done, but “the pope is on your side” strikes me as weak; when I read it my first thought was, “Well, good, because, duh! Where else should the pope be but on the side of the wounded lambs? But now he has to back up his words with some real action.”
In essentials, the statement is a good one, and if it seems “a day late” to Americans, who like things to move quickly, we can be thankful that is only a day late, and not also “a dollar short”. So to speak.
While the PA report is concerned with the abuse of minors, I do think this statement could have been stronger still had it also acknowledged the suffering and sense of betrayal experienced by those young men who have entered our seminaries full of faith and trust, only to be targeted and objectified. Such an acknowledgement would have signaled to all of us — and to the worldwide church — a recognition that the church suffers from a systemic illness the pope sees and means to address.
Meanwhile, it is a little depressing to see people on social media (and popping up on some news outlets) who are already trying to “debunk” the Grand Jury report, or “give perspective”. If they mean well, it’s just coming off like damage control and an attempt to minimize something very grave. All that does is reinforce the notion that “handling scandal”, and protecting the institutions (which is how we got here) are as important as the destructive effects of abuse and entrenched corruption on so many hearts, minds, and souls.
They are not. The Church remains the Bride of Christ, who is the Bridegroom ever-faithful. Between the love of the Bridegroom and the promptings of the Holy Spirit upon willing workers, the Church will be seen to, protected, redeemed and restored, so there is no need to rush in with wall-paper and spackle, as though human efforts at spin can do the trick.
Here is the truth: The Bride of Christ is ill, and we (in the form of his Body, the Church) are now being called to identify the causes — yes, multiple — of her affliction, so they may be vanquished. The presenting illness of 2002 has been effectively treated through the application of the Dallas Charter, but a stronger treatment — a difficult but powerful sort of chemo therapy — is clearly still needed to bring about full healing.
Precisely what kind of chemo can only be determined after a thorough, objective forensic investigation that is able to identify both the path of the corruption and its source.
This is our job — yours and mine, and our priests and leaders, all together. This is the great calling of our time: to assist the Bridegroom and the Holy Spirit in the complete restoration of the health of the Bride. If we fail, we will answer to Christ for the loss of souls, and not just the Catholic ones. The Church is the taproot of Christianity and the centering pole that provides light and breath to all the offshoot vines. Should that pole collapse, the faith of millions will be snuffed out.
We have much work to do, in so many directions, and we haven’t even fully developed some of the medicinal protocols that will be needed. Let us get to it!
Image: Public Domain
I am trying to find forgiveness in my heart and to remain non-judgmental but it is a struggle.
I fear that the Church has been corrupted by the Evil One and the Church is in need of a physical and spiritual cleansing.
For physical cleansing, in my opinion, the way to move on from the latest scandal plaguing the Church is to replace all bishops and cardinals with priests that are focused on ministry and pastoral ability and less on managerial and bureaucratical skills.
The current structure calls to mind the Sadducees; elitist, aristocratic group holding powerful positions.
For spiritual cleansing, all Catholics should unify in saying a prayer to cleanse our Church and ourselves. For one month, all Catholics in the world should unify in one prayer at one time led by the Vatican and broadcast by all media (radio, television, social media, etc.).
“Meanwhile, it is a little depressing to see people on social media (and popping up on some news outlets) who are already trying to ‘debunk’ the Grand Jury report, or ‘give perspective’.”
We need to bear in mind is that a grand jury in our justice system is a tool in the hands of a prosecutor. It hears only the evidence which the prosecutor wants it to hear to build a case against his/her target(s). Our system is an adversarial one which presumes that there can be another side which it is not the prosecutor’s job bet the defense’s to present. So a grand jury report is not intended to give the full story, like a newspaper report. It is intended to be one-sided. It should come as no surprise, much less be depressing, if persons named in the report or others say something to the effect of, “There’s more to it than what’s in the report. You also need to take this into account before you make a decision.” It would be a serious mistake to consider the report the whole story. It should be expected that there will be another side.
While there is little or no doubt about the crimes of the accused abusers, there is certainly a possibility that further information can exculpate or diminish the culpability of some of the bishops named in this adversarial document. Before judging individuals, we should want to hear what can be said in their favor. cf. Catechism, No. 2478
[…] Previous Dear Cardinal DiNardo & USCCB: Do the Right Things, and We Will Have Your Backs […]